jump to navigation

Key to Winning Without Curtis? It’s Already Here August 21, 2008

Posted by Aaron in Eagles, NFL, Philadelphia.
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
trackback

As reported earlier this week, Eagles star receiver Kevin Curtis is out with a sports hernia and will have surgery today, Thursday. There is no timetable for his comeback, as Coach Reid simply said it would be “a while.” Teams try to make it through training camp and pre-season as injury free as possible, knowing that these tune ups are exactly that, a far lesser test on players than the regular season contests. But in football injuries are unavoidable, and teams must work with what they have no matter who goes down. In this case, the Eagles are losing a prized offseason acquisition of last year in Curtis, who set career highs in 2007 in receptions (77), yards (1,110), and was the go-to guy on the outside.

Kevin Curtis will have surgery on his sports hernia Thursday (photo: Rod Mar/ The Seattle Times)

So, with an unknown date of a return from number 80, how do the Eagles patch that hole? Plenty of Eagles fans are already in full panic mode, most of them willing to give their left arm for Anquan Boldin, the unhappy stud receiver in Arizona. But according to numerous reports, that seems unlikely for the Cardinals to deal him, and frankly I don’t see the Eagles splurging another contract on Boldin or players/picks in a trade. Don’t get me wrong, having a player with the upside Boldin has would be extraordinary and I would be all for it, but in all likelihood - it’s not happening.

To take a step back, let’s look at what exactly this injury entails. We all remember McNabb playing with this same injury, but each sports hernia is different. It would have been far riskier for Curtis to try and rehab now and play through immense pain; gettin the surgery over with is essential. The healing time, although not down to an exact science, is projected at about 8 weeks. With 2 more weeks of the pre-season, that leaves Curtis out the first 6 weeks of 2008 at least; again…this injury and recovery time are hard to predict. But let’s say that it is approximately 8 weeks until he dresses, what could the solution possibly be? Well, this may sound like an Andy Reid type of answer, but the players we have now are good enough to win without him.

I’m not talking solely of the Eagles receiving core, no, but of a few other aspects that could hold the fort and win games until Curtis returns.

The first reason for hope is the offensive line and the rushing attack. Brian Westbrook is a happy man with a new contract; there’s nothing better than that. With number 36 happy and focused on football, he can return to his weekly thrashing of opposing defenses. Throw in a few pro-bowl tackles and the immensely important return (or so it seems) of Shawn Andrews, pro-bowl guard, and Brian will have a truly terrific line to run behind. The Eagles have never, ever, been a run-first football team under Reid and most likely aren’t going to change tunes in this situation. But with this ground attack, good things will happen.

Another glimmer to give fans hope is the healthy and happy Donovan McNabb. Like reporters across the country, I stood on the field and saw for myself at Lehigh what McNabb looks poised to do this year: and it’s big, big things. He comes into this season injury free for the first time in years, and without distraction. Losing his favorite true receiver (still has Westbrook) isn’t a small issue, but Donovan has been around this league a while and knows he can win without a true number 1. Hell, he’s won with Freddie Mitchell and Todd Pinkston: that’s saying something.

Lastly, and perhaps the aspect most overlooked during this “crisis”, is the other side of the ball, the defense. Have we already forgotten the signing of Super Bowl champion/pro-bowler Asante Samuel? Did we forget the rising stars on the defensive line like Patterson and Bunkley? Or the sack artist from Oakland, Chris Clemons? This Eagles defense is one of the best groups as a whole that I’ve seen in a good number of years. But like in years past, the secondary is perhaps one of the best in all of football. Brian Dawkins is nearing the end of his career, but he isn’t there yet, and is looking to regain the step he lost last year. Throw in pro-bowl snub, and best pure cover corner Sheldon Brown, Lito Sheppard (for now…), emerging playmaker Quentin Mikell, and well, you have a stacked last line of defense. Move to linebacker, where the group is young, but looking very, very good. Gaither has moved to the weak side where he should have greater success than in 2007, and Stewart Bradley is becoming less of a question mark and more of a staple. The d-line can rotate in a number of players depending on down or fatigue during a game, a very important luxury to have throughout a season.

Reid knows Asante Samuel and this defense can provide a boost this team will need (Photo:ilovebubbadogs.com)

Again, I’m not saying losing Curtis is no big deal: the guy made catch after catch and big play after big play. If we had a true number 1 last year, he would have put up numbers very similar or better to those of Wes Welker on New England. But the team must march on and on September 7th against St. Louis in the opener, they will play without their teammate and former Ram. If Reggie Brown’s hamstring is healed that will be a huge lift in itself. The other receivers to contribute will be play by committee, like the Phillies right fielders (except not so God-awful like Geoff Jenkins). DeSean Jackson is opening eyes, Avant had ok numbers last year, and let’s not forget L.J. Smith who is in a contract year: I expect him to be very good.

Do any of those guys fill number 80’s shoes? No, but they certainly help, just like McNabb, the run game, and defense will help too. And if you look at the schedule and keep in mind the estimated 6 weeks of the regular season Curtis may be out, he could potentially be back after the bye week (week 7) for the home game against Atlanta. The next 2 games after that Falcons game? At Seattle and home against the Giants: perfect timing for a comeback.

So, hope for quick healing, and if all goes well, Curtis could very well be playing in that week 8 game against Atlanta. If not, don’t throw away the season and certainly don’t panic too much. Reid is right when he says this team has a ton of talent. Is it all at receiver? Hell no, but football teams don’t win games just at receiver. This team is good enough to win without Kevin Curtis, and that’s exactly what they’re going to do.

Comments»

1. James Fayleez - August 21, 2008

This is a wonderful-pie-in-the-sky attitude here. I applaud the wishful thinking. I even almost called you “Spuds” by mistake.

Here is the bottom line: ANDY REID LOVES THE PASS.

This is a 10 year love affair. It’s never dwindled. He’s never cheated on the PASS. The PASS and Big Reid go together like milk and cookies. Peanut Butter and Jelly. Eskin and his beard.

The one thing about Andy’s girlfriend, though. He never dresses her up in nice clothes. Every year he trots her out there in Wal-Mart style clothing and keeps expecting big things. I remember one year, he took her to a big dance wearing this real wimpy Pink thing and she basically got manhandled by another guy at the party. It was so sad.

One year, Andy, splurged a little and bought his girl this beautiful, sleek outfit that she wore all season. She was the talk of the town. towards the end of the season, the dress got ripped, but she managed to make it to most important dance of the year. And she STILL looked great. Granted, the dress caught moths after the end of the season and had to be thrown out, but it was a great season nonetheless.

Now it seems like we’re back to Wal-mart clothes on Andy’s girlfriend. And even though clothes are starting to rip, little by little. She had this Brown number on and it tore, now the latest outfit she was wearing - it was a nice dress, nothing special - managed to get ripped also.

So what does Andy tell us? “I have a bunch of the old Wal-Mart stuff and it will do just fine.”

Even though, there is a beautiful evening gown on a rack out in Arizona that would make his girlfriend look SO special this year…

But keep your chin up Spuds!

2. Aaron - August 21, 2008

That’s a really strange analogy to use for the Eagles receivers, but either way you didn’t really agree or disagree to anything that was said in this article. I never said Reid/McNabb don’t love to pass; they do, and they will. How often it will work is the question, and as noted, McNabb has made it work throughout the years with your “Wal Mart” receivers. What you failed to get was that a football team will never win solely on one position. The defense, the run, and other aspects will come into play here and the Eagles are going to win some games. I never said Super Bowl, I said they’d win games.

So if that’s pie-in-the-sky attitude and just too bright and cheery for you, I do apologize for your light and unsuccessful ability to understand an article. At least you’re not TOO jaded.

3. James Fayleez - August 21, 2008

Aaron,

I thought it was a clever analogy.

My point was that if you are expecting Andy to “ramp up the running game” now that the receivers are falling one by one, don’t hold your breath. If he didn’t scale the pass last year when McNabb started the season at 75%, what gives you any hope that he’ll do it now. It’s like he can’t bring himself to let “her” (the pass) go for too long - especially with McNabb out there.

And at this point, with McNabb CLEARLY on his way out soon, I’m not looking to just “win games.” Teams that have been to four straight NFC Championship games and a Super Bowl should not be looking to just “win games.” That’s the type of attitude that a person has who will pay for a seat license and crow about a win over the Detroit Lions. It’s win it all or nothing. I’m not going to get excited about a first round playoff exit anymore.

I understand the defense has improved - at least that’s what I’m told. Why can’t the offense improve? Especially in an area where the coach loves to dabble? Why can’t we do EVERYTHING in our power to try to win it all this year?

If I seem jaded it’s because I don’t EVER see this way of thinking changing as long as Reid is the coach. He is probably the best coach we’ve ever had, but we’ve tried it his way for 10 years now. I think we’ve gone as far as we can with him.

And please no Bill Cowher analogies.

4. Aaron - August 21, 2008

I think it’s a bit strange to go back and forth on the comments of a blog, so I’ll just say two things. One, is that McNabb isn’t clearly on his way out, this is perhaps the most “unclear” its been in quite some time. He looks very, very good. Two, if we got Anquan Boldin in some strike of lightning kind of move, I wouldn’t complain. I’d be nervous past this year because his agent is you-know-who, but he would certainly help us win more games…even though I still believe we can win a good number.

5. James Fayleez - August 21, 2008

Aaron,

We’re just talking. Nothing to feel strange about. Isn’t that what your entry is supposed to inspire? And last time I looked no one else is jumping in here to discuss your topic.

Rosenhaus is a skunk, no doubt, but he’s also agent to many other players in the league. It’s just business. The Eagles can’t shy away from every client he has, there’s just too many.

If you are happy with just “winning games” then so be it. I’m not trying to rain on your parade. I just want more out of my team.

6. Aaron - August 21, 2008

Im very, very happy with winning games - thats how you win the Super Bowl. I want everything out of this team and then some. I consider myself a true die hard birds fan, born and raised. I try to write though not so much as 100 percent a fan, but a journalistic outsiders perspective. Again, I want Boldin. I just dont see it happening at all. I want a 12-4 season and a Super Bowl win, but it’s far too early to say that and a bit of a stretch. But I do truly believe that this team right now just should worry about what I said - winning games. When and if the time comes for the playoffs, we can worry about something more at that point in time.

I definitely appreciate your comments, I love talking Eagles football with fellow fans, so keep them coming. And trust me…usually I get more than one person to comment haha.


Romantic hotels in Prague | Best 3 star hotels in Rome | Top Hotels in Milan for Families with Children | My rating of Barcelona hotels | 3 star hotels in Naples